Friday, May 17, 2013

Book Review~ Undeniably Yours by Becky Wade and Blog Tour Giveaway


May 2013 by Bethany House
Paperback, 380 Pages
Women's Inspiration Fiction
Review Copy- Litfuse Tour
Warning: None
3/5- Stars

When Meg Cole’s father dies unexpectedly, she becomes the majority shareholder of his oil company and the single inheritor of his fortune. Though Meg is soft-spoken and tenderhearted–more interested in art than in oil–she’s forced to return home to Texas and to Whispering Creek Ranch to take up the reins of her father’s empire. The last thing she has the patience or the sanity to deal with? Her father’s thoroughbred racehorse farm. She gives its manager, Bo Porter, six months to close the place down.

Bo’s determined to resent the woman who’s decided to rob him of his dream. But instead of anger, Meg evokes within him a profound desire to protect. The more time he spends with her, the more he longs to overcome every obstacle that separates them–her wealth, his unworthiness, her family’s outrage–and earn the right to love her.

But just when Meg begins to realize that Bo might be the one thing on the ranch worth keeping, their fragile bond is viciously broken by a force from Meg’s past. Can their love–and their belief that God can work through every circumstance–survive.

Undeniably Yours had a small area of dramatic plot concerning our main character Meg, who suffers from anxiety and doubt, but overall the fluffy, cute romantic story-line fits in perfect with the season of Spring and will lift the mood for anyone looking for a light hearted novel.

Now that being said, while I did like this personally, and Wades writing was pleasant, what kept me from loving it is an annoying trend I continue to see in what I would call bold Christian writers who come out strong and then need to prove that they are uber-Christians because some stuffy critic or group of readers (or even the publisher) say the use of sensuality or certain provocative words could trigger someone to sin. Seriously, all things I heard during her first book release last year, some of the reviews bashed her for not being Christian enough, and it lead to blog posts and conversations that discussed Inspy fiction and how off base most of the books are.

When Im looking to read CF I've set the bar high, and only because with most of the books offered to women (especially by other women) we have the overuse of scripture and moral preaching, and a living standard that alienates a huge part of the audience. You can pick up a Ted Dekker book or a Travis Thrasher book and be shocked at there use of words, sexuality and paranormal activities and its mostly hands down accepted, and also gains the authors more readers outside of the Inspy circle, which seems like a double standard in what women can write and what men can write and get away with in the CF publishing world. Sounds harsh but that's what I see as a reader of both the general and CBA market.

Im disappointed that this book fell into the typical arc we see in so many of these sappy, publisher/catered reader driven plot-lines which includes this many prayers, and this many mentions of God, and this many revelations, and this many sermons, and this many skirt around the issues, and this many perfect outcomes that never lead to sin, struggle or temptation. Oh yes there might be a character suffering or trying to deal with an issue like Meg's anxiety but the issue is always sugar-coated. Sugar coating never works for me in a story, it makes the characters unrelatable and causes an immediate disconnect. Ill give it to Wade that she certainly takes chances when displaying real life emotions and desires that the characters are internalizing, but for these characters in this particular book, it didn't come across that strong.

Of course I could be wrong, but I feel like this sophomore effort was more damage control to prove to Wades critics that she is indeed a solid Christian writer. There was a lot of time spent on convincing the reader that her wholesome, lightly flawed characters had issues but maintained a nonstop inner dialog with God, so much so that it seemed inserted just for insertion sake and not an authentic portrayal of faith. From her bold debut My Stubborn Heart, which presented the faith aspect with subtle genius, I felt that the overuse of "Im a Christian character" almost immediately distract me from the story.

While this approach will make plenty of people happy, I feel its sad that only exclusive Christian readers will pick it up. I overall enjoyed the book for the story sake, but missed the authentic feel I loved from Wade's first.

~To follow the entire tour and enter for the Fire Kindle go HERE.
Thanks to Bethany House for Review Copy
Photobucket

2 comments:

  1. Melissas Eclectic BookshelfMay 17, 2013 at 12:01 PM

    This is exactly why I avoid Christian Fiction...well that and the fact that I am not technically a Christian....lol. If the faith portrayed seems genuine and realistic, I have no issues with preachiness...but the majority just seem so completely unbelievable that it takes away from the plot line.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Astrology BooksMay 18, 2013 at 5:16 AM

    I did not find this book at my favorite online bookstore.. Suggest me from where to order books online... I wanna read this one asap.. :)

    ReplyDelete

I love comments!! Thanks for taking the time to do so. Warning: Spam and trolls will self destruct.

Currently Reading.....